FINDING · AA-009
Reason provenance inconsistent in original notice
Stable evidence, challenge and retest links.
Observation
Original notice cites credit history, which is absent from the supplied principal-factor record. Corrected mapping replay is supported by the same record; production deployment has not been assessed.
The original notice remains inconsistent. Closed refers to the corrected synthetic sandbox replay, not deployed notices or legal compliance.
Evidence chain
Object chronology
Original reason contradicts the supplied principal-factor record.
Inspect previous and new state
{
"before": null,
"after": {
"status": "Open",
"evidence": [
"EV-002",
"EV-003"
]
}
}Request supporting evidence
Inspect previous and new state
{
"before": null,
"after": {
"originId": "AA-009",
"question": "Reconcile notice reason M-17 with the supplied principal factors."
}
}M-17 incorrectly mapped utilization to credit-history wording. MAP-3.5-TEST maps utilization to the corresponding stated factor. The original notice remains preserved. Replay only, not a production release.
Inspect previous and new state
{
"before": {
"status": "Awaiting response"
},
"after": {
"status": "Response received",
"responseId": "RESP-019-1",
"artifactIds": [
"EV-003",
"EV-014"
]
}
}Corrected mapper replay supplied; independent review still required.
Inspect previous and new state
{
"before": {
"status": "Open"
},
"after": {
"status": "Retest required",
"retestId": "RT-009"
}
}Compared original notice, principal factors and corrected replay. Both replay reasons are supported. Closure scope is the synthetic mapping defect only.
Inspect previous and new state
{
"before": {
"status": "Response received"
},
"after": {
"status": "Supported",
"responseId": "RESP-019-1"
}
}EV-014 replay is supported. Closure limited to sandbox mapping; no production remediation claim.
Inspect previous and new state
{
"before": {
"status": "Retest required"
},
"after": {
"status": "Closed",
"retestId": "RT-009"
}
}